Remembering Chef Peggy Magister of Crazy Water 

Longtime Milwaukee Chef Peggy Magister, 65, passed away on June 7, 2024 after a short battle with cancer.

Best known for her restaurant, Crazy Water, Peggy was a talented chef who introduced the City of Milwaukee to “California Style” cuisine, a predecessor of farm-to-table and New American cuisines that integrated fresh, seasonal vegetables and globally influenced ingredients. Though she didn’t know it at the time, she’d also blaze a trail for other chefs, planting the seed for the restaurant row that developed on South Second Street in Walker’s Point.

I got to know Magister largely through her expertly prepared food. But I also had the privilege of sitting beside her – often at the table in the front window at Crazy Water – to chat about her background, her plans and her hopes for the future. In addition to cooking she loved to garden, and fresh produce from her home plot in Elkhorn, Wisconsin was often the source of inspiration (and sometimes specials at the restaurant).

The Peggy I got to know was humble, passionate and generous. When my first book was released in the autumn of 2015, she was among the first to call and congratulate me on the accomplishment. Even more, she offered to host my book launch party at the restaurant, preparing a generous spread of appetizers for the attendees.

I’m far from the only one to have benefited from her talents and gracious nature. In fact, it’s no understatement to say that the impact of her work – which assisted in changing the palate of Milwaukee diners and built foundations for the current dining scene – will not be easily forgotten. 

Sitting in the Crazy Water dining room watching Chef Peggy Magister at work on a busy evening was always a sight to behold. It was almost a blur as she and her small staff whisked ingredients from prep to pan and onto plate. But the motions were fluid, and the timing impressive as they served up dish after dish from the helm of a 10-by-10-foot open kitchen.

Magister, a Marquette University graduate who began her career in nursing, was a relative late-comer to the culinary world. In search of a change, she moved to California at the age of 30 to attend the California Culinary Academy in San Francisco. While earning her degree, she got a job working with Wolfgang Puck at his restaurant Postrio.

After returning to the Milwaukee area, she worked at Steven Wade’s Café as well as Chip & Pye’s in Mequon. That’s where she met her partner Tony Betzhold. Together, he and Magister launched a catering company and opened The Fork Café, a boulangerie in Cedarburg. But when the restaurant wasn’t doing as well as Magister had hoped, she decided to move to Milwaukee. There she worked at the newly minted The Knick and North Shore Bistro while searching for a place to call her own.

X

Crazy Water was born in 2002 when Magister and Betzhold snatched up the former home of German bar Zur Krone and transformed it into an eclectic restaurant serving fresh, California-style cuisine. Betzhold handled the business end of things while Magister took charge of the cooking alongside Chef Emanuel Corona, who’d worked beside her at The Fork Café. 

At the time, there weren’t many restaurants in Walker’s Point. Barossa hadn’t yet settled into the former Dish Night Club and La Merenda wouldn’t arrive until 2006. But Kevin Sloan’s The Social, which had opened in 2001, was doing well on the northerly side of South Second Street gave Magister hope that the nearby location could succeed.

“I wanted to contribute,” Magister noted in a 2014 interview. “Not many people were doing California-style cuisine. And the restaurant was small enough that I didn’t need many people to fill it, so I held my breath and hoped people would embrace it.”

And embrace it they did, swarming to the restaurant for a taste of Magister’s cooking. Starters like yuzu-marinated pork belly, chorizo-stuffed dates and escargot in tomato concassé were served alongside signature main dishes like grilled flat iron steak and “crazy shrimp,” a dish featuring Asian barbecue-sauced shrimp served with chorizo and tomatoes over rice with jalapeño corn bread muffins. 

The restaurant’s reputation for impeccable, inventive fare attracted diners from across the city in the days before the Walker’s Point neighborhood would become a dining destination, attracting restaurants like La Merenda, Ginger Tapas Bar, Transfer Pizzeria, The Noble, Braise, Morel and more. 

In 2010, Magister’s work was recognized nationally when she was honored as a James Beard semi-finalist in the category of Best Chef Midwest. The award highlighted her talent as a chef and further cemented the restaurant’s place on the Milwaukee dining map.

X

Unawares, Magister was also building her legacy as she passed along her knowledge and expertise to a new generation.

In 2013, she took on a new challenge when she opened the upscale small plates restaurant, AP Bar and Kitchen, alongside her nephew Justin Anthony. Anthony managed the front of house and Magister took the helm in the kitchen, serving dishes like fried catfish with malt vinegar, sweetbreads, baby octopus panzanella salad, and fried chicken with soy ginger vinaigrette and kimchee. There was an oyster bar, craft cocktails, and an expertly curated wine list focused on European-style…